Available now in paperback and on Kindle
Illustration for A Clock Nobody Wound

© 2026 Casey Spitnale

← All chapters

Chapter 25

A Clock Nobody Wound

My Times Are in Your Hands

“The time memory of certain social insects (bees, ants, termites) is on a higher level. These animals, after ‘training,’ are capable of determining any hour of the day, and their time memory is independent of external periodicities.”
❖
I. von Stein-Beling (Ingeborg Beling), Biological Reviews, 1935

In 1929, Ingeborg Beling showed that a bee keeps a working internal clock even shut away from daylight. Casey uses this chapter to trace what nearly a century of researchers did with that discovery, and to draw a contrast between the bee's timing and the best human engineering of its own era. At Petersburg in 1864, Lieutenant Colonel Pleasants' mine went off more than an hour late because a fuse died at a splice, and two men had to crawl back into a tunnel packed with gunpowder to relight it by hand. Wahl's bees, tested the same century in a salt mine shielded from nearly all cosmic radiation, kept perfect time without anyone checking on them at all. Nobody had to climb back down and fix anything. That contrast is the chapter's real argument. Every attempt to explain the bee's clock as something ordinary, background radiation, a general habit, an outside signal picked up like a radio broadcast, failed under testing. What was left standing each time was more exact than an accident has any business being: nine tracked feeding times, a learned schedule that transplants along with the brain tissue that holds it, memory precise enough to bind what, where, and when into one recollection. Casey reads that pattern through Romans 1:20 and Ecclesiastes 3:1 together: a built-in sense of timing, in a creature too small to know it's demonstrating anything, is exactly the kind of invisible quality Paul says gets made visible in what's been built.

Bee Science

Wahl's 1932 salt-mine control
bees tested for time-memory deep in a salt mine, shielded from nearly all cosmic radiation, kept perfect time anyway, ruling out radiation as the cue they were reading (exact depth/location of the mine unverified — see notes below)
The bee's clock meets the tests later used to define a circadian clock
it keeps running with no outside cue; left alone it settles into a period a shade under twenty-four hours; Beling could not train it to a nineteen-hour day; and it ran at the same speed at 73 and 88 degrees Fahrenheit, though temperature speeds up almost every other chemical process in a living body. The word circadian did not exist yet. The nineteen-hour result also shows a limit: bees could learn a feeding hour within a day but could not follow any schedule the researcher chose
Why a bee learns feeding times: the flowers keep hours
Kleber found that many plants release nectar or pollen on a daily schedule, so a bee that arrives at the wrong hour may find nothing; she ruled out simple hunger as the reason for the bee's return, and the learned time matched the plant's rhythm
A bee can juggle up to nine feeding times a day
Rudolf Koltermann pushed Wahl's five-or-six-appointment finding to nine separate daily feeding times, each only forty-five minutes apart and tagged with its own scent or color cue
Mushroom-body transplant transfers a learned feeding time
transplanting the mushroom bodies (the part of an insect's brain used for learning and memory) from evening-trained donor bees into midday-trained hosts put the hosts on the donor's schedule within three to five days; this tied the learned feeding time to a specific part of the brain, though it is more than the experiment showed to call it moving a whole memory from one bee to another
Episodic-like memory: what, where, and when together
bees trained to expect one flower pattern at one location each morning and a different pattern/location each afternoon scored 83 percent correct overall, and 91 percent in one stripped-down color-only test, evidence of bound "what-where-when" memory, a term borrowed from scrub-jay caching research
The hive sets the young bee's clock
in whole field colonies, newly emerged bees that spent their first two days in the colony kept the colony's time, while sisters kept alone had weaker rhythms and drifted out of step; bees caged individually inside the hive fell into step too, though less tightly, behind a double screen that kept sisters from touching them. When the team set the colony against the room's lamps (opening the hive entrance on a different schedule), the young bees kept the colony's hours rather than the lamps' in three of four runs. The researchers called it the first evidence that a social signal can override light as the thing that sets a clock
Cited research (8)
  • Beling (1929), Zeitschrift für vergleichende Physiologie 9(2): 259-338: The founding 1929 doctoral thesis proving a honeybee keeps a working, roughly 24-hour internal clock even sealed away from every external time cue
  • Wahl (1932), Zeitschrift für vergleichende Physiologie 16: 529-589: Ran the salt-mine cosmic-radiation control and the untrained-bee control confirming Beling's result was a specific trained memory, not general bee behavior
  • Kleber (1935), Zeitschrift für vergleichende Physiologie 22: 221-262: Traced the bee's time memory to the flowers' own daily nectar/pollen release schedule, ruling out plain hunger as the driver
  • Koltermann (1971), Zeitschrift für vergleichende Physiologie 75: 49-68: Found a bee can hold nine separate feeding appointments in a single day, 45 minutes apart, each tagged by scent or color
  • Martin, Martin & Lindauer (1978), Journal of Comparative Physiology 124: 193-201: Mushroom-body transplant experiments: a learned feeding time transfers from donor to host bee within 3-5 days
  • Martin, Lindauer & Martin (1983), Sitzungsberichte der Bayerischen Akademie der Wissenschaften: A later Würzburg team revisiting what sets the bee's clock; Wahl's radiation test was still on their list of explanations already ruled out
  • Pahl et al. (2007): Established honeybee 'episodic-like memory,' what, where, and when bound together in one recollection, a term borrowed from scrub-jay caching research
  • Fuchikawa, T., Eban-Rothschild, A., Nagari, M., Shemesh, Y. & Bloch, G. (2016), "Potent social synchronization can override photic entrainment of circadian rhythms," Nature Communications 7: 11662: the colony sets young bees' clocks, and in three of four trials overrode the room's light cycle

Scripture

Anchor: Romans 1:20

Also touches

Ecclesiastes 3:1Job 12:7, 10Psalm 90:12Romans 1:20Psalm 31:15

Civil War Recordcivil war

The Petersburg Mine / Battle of the Crater, July 30, 1864

  • Lt. Col. Henry Pleasants had the men of his own 48th Pennsylvania, most of them anthracite miners from Schuylkill County, dig a 510-foot tunnel under the Confederate line at Petersburg, packed at the far end with four tons of gunpowder
  • Pleasants lit the fuse at 3:15 a.m. on July 30, 1864, set to blow at 3:30; more than an hour past that time, nothing had happened
  • Sergeant Henry "Snapper" Reese and Lieutenant Jacob Douty crawled back into the tunnel not knowing whether the powder would explode under their own boots, found the fuse had died at a splice, spliced and relit it themselves; the mine finally exploded at 4:44 a.m., killing close to three hundred Confederate soldiers instantly
  • The mine left a crater the manuscript gives as a hundred and seventy feet long and thirty feet deep (the draft cited Encyclopedia Virginia and American Battlefield Trust; the final text dropped its inline citations). Digging the tunnel took about a month. Casey's earlier note kept the crater's width out over source discrepancies; length and depth are new in the manuscript and are not checked in the notes files
  • Grant called the botched follow-up assault, which bogged down inside the crater itself, "the saddest affair I have witnessed in this war"; nearly thirty-eight hundred Union men were lost
  • Facts were cross-checked against two independent sources (Encyclopedia Virginia for the exact fuse timing and both volunteers' names; American Battlefield Trust for tunnel length, powder amount, and Grant's quote); minor source discrepancies on tunnel length (510 vs. 586 ft) and crater width (60-100 ft) were resolved by using the American Battlefield Trust figures already established as this project's citation family, with crater width left out of the manuscript entirely rather than picking an unverified number
Primary sources (2)
  • Encyclopedia Virginia
  • American Battlefield Trust

verified

From the Book

In 1929, a German graduate student named Ingeborg Beling set out to see whether bees could tell time. She trained them to find sugar water at the same hour every day. Then she sealed them in a room with the sun shut out entirely, with no daylight and no change in temperature. They still showed up at the right hour. Nothing but a clock inside the bee herself told her when to go, the way some people wake up a minute before the alarm. “There is a time for everything, and a season for every activity under the heavens.” (Ecclesiastes 3:1) A colleague of Beling’s named Oskar Wahl spent 1932 closing every door the skeptics could still point to. Some wondered whether cosmic radiation, which reaches us from space all the time, was setting the bees’ schedule. So Wahl took his bees down into a working salt mine, under enough rock to block nearly all of it. The bees kept perfect time anyway. Whatever they were reading, it wasn’t coming down from the sky.

Get the full book →
Get the Book